Ingredients
Equipment
Instructions
- Make the seasoned butter. Melt the butter in a 2-cup glass measuring cup in the microwave. Add the Parmesan, lemon zest, lemon juice, green onions, parsley, Zippy Sicilian and red pepper flakes. Stir well.
- Prepare the oysters. Place one shucked oyster into each clean oyster shell. Arrange the shells on a baking sheet and spoon the seasoned butter generously over each oyster, allowing some of the mixture to settle around the oyster in the cup of the shell.
- Prepare for serving. Before grilling, have lemon wedges, hot sauce, saltines or garlic bread, plates and napkins ready. The oysters cook quickly and are best eaten immediately.
- Heat the grill. Preheat a gas or charcoal grill to high heat.
- Grill the oysters. Carry the oysters to the grill on the baking sheet, then transfer the individual shells directly to the grill grate. Grill for approximately 4–6 minutes, until the butter is bubbling and the oysters are just cooked through.
- Watch for flare-ups. Some butter may spill from the shells and cause brief flare-ups. Move an oyster if a flare becomes sustained rather than momentary.
- Serve immediately. Transfer the shells back to the platter and serve while the oysters are bubbling hot.
Notes
- About the butter: Salted or unsalted butter both work. If using salted butter, taste before adding any additional salt.
- Keep it simple: There is no need to make compound butter, chill it or cut it into pats. Melt, stir, spoon and grill.
- About Zippy Sicilian: Our house seasoning adds herbs, garlic, pepper and a little extra zip. If you don’t have it, substitute a robust Italian herb blend and adjust the garlic, salt and red pepper to taste.
- About the shells: Real oyster shells work better than the small metal substitutes because their deeper cups hold both the oyster and the seasoned butter. Wash previously used shells thoroughly, run them through the dishwasher without the heat-dry cycle and allow them to dry completely before storing.
- Gas or charcoal: We recommend a gas grill for oysters because they cook in only 4–6 minutes. Charcoal is wonderful if you’ll be grilling something else afterward.
- For a crowd: Figure on at least four oysters per person, and six to eight for enthusiastic oyster eaters.
- Eat them now: Grilled oysters are not patient food. Have everything—and everyone—ready before they go onto the grill. This is not the time to finish another side dish, hunt for the hot sauce or take twenty-seven photographs.
